BuddhaJones
HOME | ABOUT | MOBILE | RSS | WHAT IS NICHIREN BUDDHISM? | HOW TO USE THIS SITE

An Analysis of Eating Restrictions in Buddhist Culture

by: clown hidden

Wed Mar 24, 2010 at 10:15:17 AM MDT


A litle over a month ago COS had raised a question about Buddhism and vegetarianism. I was searching on line for information about meat eating in Hinduism and Buddhism and found this essay by Nick Kembel which I thought some of you might find worth reading.

http://www.shabkar.org/downloa...

"There once was a great monk who, out of compassion for all
sentient beings, was a strict vegetarian. In fact, he claimed he
had never in his lifetime consumed the flesh of any animal.
One lady, deciding to test the monk's claim, prepared a dish
for the monk. She told him it contained only vegetables, but in
fact it contained a small piece of meat. The monk gratefully
accepted the dish and the lady left, believing she had fooled
him. However, the monk saw through her trick, and tossed the
dish down to the earth. The next morning he awoke, and
found that the food, embedded in the earth, had sprouted into
2 shrubs: one garlic and one onion. This is why Buddhists do
not eat garlic and onions."

http://www.shabkar.org/downloa...

clown hidden :: An Analysis of Eating Restrictions in Buddhist Culture
Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Garlic and onions
Wow. This is the first time I've heard that Buddhists supposedly don't or shouldn't eat garlic or onions. I had heard that some serious yoga practitioners avoid these things, along with vinegar, alcohol, etc. (link for more info.)

It cracks me up that the anecdote you cited offers no doctrinal rationale for avoiding garlic and onions, just the implication that these foods sprouted from a dirty trick to undermine the noble efforts of a practitioner. Bizarre assertion. Anyway -- thanks, Clown. food for thought.


Vegetarianism
I just wanted to thank everyone for there input on the subject.

I have been a vegetarian for approx. a month; I definitely have developed more compassion for all life and feel good about the change.


Austerity
Well, there, then, now. I don't know too much, but I know diet is important to health. I know some individuals that being a strict vegitarian is actually disadvantagious to their health. So IMO being a vegitarian doesn't have jack to do with Buddhism except on a subjective level.    

elective
What I found interesting is that while the author is a vegan, the way I read it, he was saying that vegetarianism is not required in buddhism and that it was/is mostly just a social custom.

[ Parent ]
Restrictions
Sorry but I'm confused as to what you're referring to.
Something other than the parable of the monk who never ate flesh and why Buddhists don't eat garlic and onions? Because that is totally about what Buddhists supposedly do and don't do, not social custom.  

[ Parent ]
there's more
If you look there's a link. That story is just the begining. The article talks a lot more about the history of diet and buddhism.

[ Parent ]
The Author's Conclussion
The author's own conclussion: "If one genuinely wishes to reduce the suffering of all sentient beings, I believe refraining from eating meat is essential."
This is not what you have concluded that the artical is about at all. The author's arguement is based on authorative bias, which is just ordinary bias which may have started as cultural but he has adopted as doctrine, which in turn is a useless austerity having nothing to do with either compassion or Buddhism.  

[ Parent ]
opinion
That was his opinion. But his synopsis of the history shows that vegetarianism was always optional for buddhists. Which I think is a correst reading of the history.
As far as his opinion goes,if you said that you wanted to reduce the suffering of all living beings and at the same time you killed more of them than you had to I would see a disconnect there so I wouldn't disagree either.
What argument can be made that compassion does not require minimizing killing of animals?

[ Parent ]
Compassion
Thanks clown,
you've got me thinking now about that Lanza/Chopra biocentrism crap and how they assigned meaning to gaps in evidence with unsubstantiated biased presumtions and how individuals may at times do the same for a blanketed lable they term compassion.    

[ Parent ]
is name calling an argument?
Just to reiterate I eat meat but I don't claim to be compassionate to all living beings.
If there is an argument that to kill more animals than is necessary to sustain life just to satisfy your taste is having compassion for all living beings I would like to hear it.
If a sociopath feels no guilt in killing humans is it alright for them to do so?
Why don't we kill and eat dogs and cats like we do chicken pigs and cows? There doesn't seem to be a law against it as long as your not stealing someone's pet.
The French eat horse meat, the Koreans eat dog and some tribes in Papua New Guinea eat each other.


[ Parent ]
My Personal Socio-Path
I remember my fathers words to me. He said, "Son, if indeed you are my son, as you go through life you'll find one of the best things about being a sociopath is that you'll never get your feelings hurt." He was as right as he was delicious! (With a fine chianti of course)

[ Parent ]
close knit family
Family values are important to a viable culture.

[ Parent ]
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forgot your username or password?

Message Boards

Search




Advanced Search

Wiki Links
Fuju-fuse

Nichiren Shoshu

Nichiren Shu

Nipponzan Myohoji

Rissho Kosei Kai

Shoshinkai

Bookshelf Classics

Buddha by Karen Armstrong

Buddhism Without Beliefs by Stephen Batchelor

Cutting Through Spiritual Materialism by Chogyam Trungpa

Modern Buddhist Healing by Charles Atkins

Opening the Heart of the Cosmos: Insights on the Lotus Sutra by Thich Nhat Hanh

Riding The Wheel To Wellness: A Buddhist Perspective On Life's Healing Gifts, Meditation, Prayer & Visualization by Charles Atkins

Shambhala: The Sacred Path of the Warrior by Chogyam Trungpa

Threefold Lotus Sutra by Bunno Kato

When Things Fall Apart: Heart Advice for Difficult Times by Pema Chodron

The Wisdom of No Escape by Pema Chodron

Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind by Shunryu Suzuki

Daily Feeds

Fraught Feeds

Sites to See

Angry Asian Buddhist

A Buddhist Catholic

Alltop Buddhism

Barbara's Buddhism Blog

Buddhism Examiner

Buddhist Channel

Daily Scoldings

The Endless Further

Former SGI Member Forum

Gohonzon Galleries

Gongyo on Line

How Cults Work

Jacqueline I. Stone

Lotus Sutra in English

Martin Bradley's Gosho Translations

The Nichiren Sangha

Nichiren's Coffeehouse

One City

Precious Metal

Rougebuddha

Ryuei's Books and Essays

SGI Obituaries

Shodaigyo Streaming

Smilin' Buddha Cabaret

Soka Gakkai Unofficial

Soka Member

Whiskey River

Worst Horse



HOME
Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is published under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike License.
Read and participate at your own risk.

Powered by: SoapBlox